Choosing the right exercise intensity is essential for safe and effective training, especially during recovery from a concussion. While many fitness programs rely on a heart rate cardio prescription based on a percentage of maximum heart rate, this approach may not work for everyone. Changes in heart rate response after a concussion can make traditional heart rate targets inaccurate, leading to exercise that is either too easy or too demanding. Understanding these limitations can help athletes, coaches, and healthcare professionals make better decisions and prescribe cardio based on workload rather than heart rate alone.
Heart Rate Cardio Prescription
Understanding Heart Rate After Concussion
Many fitness programs recommend exercising at 70% of your maximum heart rate. However, this method is not always accurate, especially for people recovering from a concussion. Research shows that a concussion can change how the heart responds to physical activity. As a result, some individuals experience a heart rate that rises too quickly, while others struggle to increase it enough. Therefore, relying on heart rate alone may not reflect the actual effort being made.
Why 70% Max Heart Rate Can Be Misleading
Normally, heart rate is used as an indicator of exercise intensity. Nevertheless, a concussion may disrupt the autonomic nervous system, causing abnormal heart rate responses. For example, one person may reach 70% of their maximum heart rate with very little effort because their heart rate spikes unusually fast. In contrast, another person may have to work much harder because their heart rate barely increases. Consequently, both individuals would be exercising at completely different workloads despite showing the same heart rate.
A Better Way to Prescribe Cardio
Instead of prescribing a target heart rate, a standardized workload is often a more reliable approach. For instance, clinicians can set a fixed resistance or power output on a stationary bike that would typically produce about 70% maximum heart rate in healthy individuals. This method ensures the exercise intensity remains consistent regardless of how the person’s heart responds. Furthermore, it reduces the risk of overtraining or undertraining during recovery.
The Key Takeaway
Ultimately, heart rate should be viewed as one piece of the puzzle rather than the only measurement. Recent discussions in sports science also emphasize that heart rate is a physiological signal that requires context, not an absolute measure of exercise intensity. Tracking workload, symptoms, and recovery together provides a more accurate picture of progress, particularly after neurological injuries such as concussions.
Join the Coaches Academy and start building your career in pro sport.
Join Now → https://preparelikeaproacademy.com.au/join-coaches-now/
